Skip to main
Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar
  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Pizza & Wings Specials
  • Every Day Specials
  • Pizza
  • Wings
  • Panini
  • Cold Subs
  • Hot Subs
  • Pastas
  • Calzones & Rolls
  • Tossed Salads
  • Greens
  • Sides
  • Desserts
  • Beverages
  • Catering Menu
  • Happy Hour

Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar Menu

3899 Oneida St, New Hartford, NY

3899 Oneida St, New Hartford, NY

·

  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Pizza & Wings Specials
  • Every Day Specials
  • Pizza
  • Wings
  • Panini
  • Cold Subs
  • Hot Subs
  • Pastas
  • Calzones & Rolls
  • Tossed Salads
  • Greens
  • Sides
  • Desserts
  • Beverages
  • Catering Menu
  • Happy Hour

Most ordered

  • Large (16") Cheese Pizza.

    Large (16") Cheese Pizza

    $21.50

  • Large 2 Topping & 30 Bone In Wings.

    Large 2 Topping & 30 Bone In Wings

    $56.00+

  • Small (12") Cheese Pizza.

    Small (12") Cheese Pizza

    $15.00

  • 20 Wings.

    20 Wings

    $27.50+

  • Small Pizza & 10 Bone In Wings.

    Small Pizza & 10 Bone In Wings

    $27.00+

  • 10 Wings.

    10 Wings

    $15.00+

  • 12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza.

    12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza

    $21.50

  • Large 2 Topping & 30 Boneless Wings.

    Large 2 Topping & 30 Boneless Wings

    $51.00+


Appetizers

Meatballs & Long Hots

$15.00

Mozzarella Sticks

8 sticks. choose your sauce: marinara, bbq, blue cheese, honey mustard.

$12.50

Mozzarella Sticks.

Chicken Tenders

Choose your sauce: marinara, honey mustard, ranch, blue cheese, bbq or no sauce.

$13.00+

Chicken Tenders.

Boneless Wings

$12.00+

Sweet Potato Fries

$11.00

Onion Rings

$11.00

Greens Ala Tony

Escarole, garlic & spices, salami, prosciutto, hot soppressata, hot cherry peppers, onions, potatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese & breadcrumbs.

$18.00

Jalapeno Poppers

$13.00

French Fries

Fried potatoes.

$6.00

French Fries.

Buffalo Chicken Fries

$15.00

Fried Bologna & Long Hots

$12.00


Pizza & Wings Specials

Large 2 Topping & 30 Bone In Wings

$56.00+

Large 2 Topping & 30 Bone In Wings.

Large 2 Topping & 30 Boneless Wings

$51.00+

Large 2 Topping & 30 Boneless Wings.

Large Cheese & 10 Boneless Wings

$32.00+

Large 1 Topping / Small 1 Topping

$34.00

Large 1 Topping / Small 1 Topping.

LG. Cheese 20 Boneless, LG Antipasto & 2 Liter

$53.00+

Small Pizza & 10 Bone In Wings

$27.00+

Small Pizza & 10 Bone In Wings.

Small & 10 Boneless

$25.00+

Small Cheese & 20 Bone In Wings

$38.00+

Small Cheese & 20 Bone In Wings.

Small Cheese & 20 Boneless Wings

$33.00+


Every Day Specials

Managers Special

LG. Cheese (1 Topping) 24 Bone-In Wings, 5 Garlic Knots, LG Antipasto & 2 liter

$50.00+

Grilled Reuben & Fries

$18.75

Friday Only : Jumbo Fish Fry

Only available on fridays: 11 oz. beer battered haddock, 1 pound fries, cole slaw, clam chowder.

$20.00

Friday Only : Jumbo Fish Fry.

10 Oz. Cheeseburger

Choose your veggies, dressing and cheese. lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles mayo, ketchup, mustard american, provolone, swiss, mozzarella

$16.50

10 Oz. Cheeseburger.

Thursday Spaghetti & Meatballs

Eat In Only

$10.00

Calabrese Panini

Italian dressing, romaine, tomato, red onion, capicola, salami, hot soppressata, provolone, Italian giardiniera. Toasted.

$17.50

Meatballa Parm Panini

Marinara, meatballs, black pepper, pecorino romano, mozzarella. Toasted

$17.50

Roast Beef Panini

Horseradish mayo, onions, thin sliced roast beef, smoked gouda cheese, toasted

$18.75

Steak & Greens Panini

Mayo, hot celery peppers. seasoned greens, Pecorino Romano, and mozzarella. Toasted

$18.75

The Cubano Panini

Mustard, ham, pickles, roasted pork tenderloin, pepperjack cheese. Toasted

$18.00

The Tony Panini

Layered breaded eggplant, marinara, roasted red peppers, artichokes, ricotta, peppers, mozzarella, pecorino romano. Toasted.

$17.50

Tuscan Turkey Panini

Pesto mayo, italian dressing, iceberg, tomato, onion, sliced turkey, pepperoncini, roasted red peppers, provolone. Toasted.

$17.50

Tuscan Turkey Panini.

The King BLT

$18.00

The Beast Triple Decker

$27.00

Fried Bologna & Long Hots

$12.00

2 Double Cheeseburger Meal

2 double quarter pounder with cheese burgers. As is. Additional toppings need to be chosen if needed. Comes with a side of waffle fries.

$11.95


Pizza

Large (16") Cheese Pizza

$21.50

Large (16") Cheese Pizza.

Large (16") Garlic Pizza

$21.50

Large (16") Garlic Pizza.

Sicilian Style Crust Pizza

$21.50

Sicilian Style Crust Pizza.

Large (16") Tomato Pie Pizza

$16.00

Large Upside Down Pizza

$21.50

Large Chicken Wing Pizza

$30.00

Large (16") Mediterranean Pizza

Garlic base topped with baby spinach, roasted red peppers, artichokes, kalamata olives, fresh mushrooms, feta cheese, extra virgin olive oil & pecorino romano

$42.00

Large Garlic & Pickle

Garlic base with mozzarella cheese and pickles

$28.00

Large Garlic & Pickle.

Large Five Cheese

Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, ricotta & pecorino romano on a light garlic base

$33.00

Large Five Cheese.

Large The Amore

Sausage, hot cherry peppers, roasted peppers & onions

$34.00

Large The Amore.

Large Stuffed Pizza

$42.00

Small (12") Cheese Pizza

$15.00

Small (12") Cheese Pizza.

Small (12") Garlic Pizza

$15.00

Small (12") Garlic Pizza.

12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza

$21.50

12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza.

Small Upside Down Pizza

$15.00

Small Chicken Wing Pizza

$20.00

Small Chicken Wing Pizza.

Small (12") Mediterranean Pizza

Garlic base topped with baby spinach, roasted red peppers, artichokes, kalamata olives, fresh mushrooms, feta cheese, extra virgin olive oil & pecorino romano

$28.00

Small Garlic Pickle

Garlic base with mozzarella cheese and pickles

$19.00

Small Garlic Pickle.

Small 5 Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, ricotta & pecorino romano on a light garlic base

$24.00

Small The Amore

Sausage, hot cherry peppers, roasted peppers & onions

$24.00

Small The Amore.

Small Stuffed Pizza

$25.00

Tray Pizza (17X25)

All trays need a 2 hour notice to make & pick up

$42.00

Tray Garlic Pizza

All trays need a 2 hour notice to make & pick up

$42.00


Wings

10 Wings

$15.00+

10 Wings.

20 Wings

$27.50+

20 Wings.

30 Wings

$41.25+

40 Wings

$55.00+

40 Wings.

50 Wings

$66.00+

100 Wings

$115.00+

Xtra Blue Cheese

$2.50+

Xtra Celery

$2.50+

Xtra Wing Sauce

$2.50+


Panini

Calabrese Panini

Italian dressing, romaine, tomato, red onion, capicola, salami, hot soppressata, provolone, Italian giardiniera. Toasted.

$17.50

Steak & Greens Panini

Mayo, hot celery peppers. seasoned greens, Pecorino Romano, and mozzarella. Toasted

$18.75

Meatballa Parm Panini

Marinara, meatballs, black pepper, pecorino romano, mozzarella. Toasted

$17.50

Tuscan Turkey Panini

Pesto mayo, italian dressing, iceberg, tomato, onion, sliced turkey, pepperoncini, roasted red peppers, provolone. Toasted.

$17.50

Tuscan Turkey Panini.

The Tony Panini

Layered breaded eggplant, marinara, roasted red peppers, artichokes, ricotta, peppers, mozzarella, pecorino romano. Toasted.

$17.50

The Cubano Panini

Mustard, ham, pickles, roasted pork tenderloin, pepperjack cheese. Toasted

$18.00

Roast Beef Panini

Horseradish mayo, onions, thin sliced roast beef, smoked gouda cheese, toasted

$18.75


Cold Subs

Large Turkey Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$9.99

Large Turkey Sub.

Mixed Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$9.99

Ham & Cheese Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$9.99

Large Roast Beef

Choose dressing, veggies, cheese

$17.00

Large Roast Beef.

Salami Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$15.00

Cappy Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$16.00

Pepperoni Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$16.00

Prosciutto Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$17.00

Tuna Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$15.00

Veggie Cold Sub

Please select what you would like on your sub.

$15.00

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Caesar dressing, romaine, red onion, grilled chicken, mozzarella, pecorino romano

$13.00

Chicken Caesar Wrap.

Large The Italiano

Cappy, prosciutto, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and Italian dressing. Topped with an gardinera Please select what you would like on your sub.

$16.00

Large The Italiano.

Hot Subs

Large Meatball Parm

$15.00

Large Chicken Parm

$15.00

Large Chicken Parm.

Large Chicken Club

$15.00

Large Buffalo Chicken Sub

$15.00+

Large Chicken BBQ Sub

$16.00

Large Eggplant Sub

$15.00

Large Steak Sub

Grilled mushrooms, peppers, onions, shaved steak, mozzarella cheese. toasted.

$17.00

Large BBQ Beef

$17.00

Large BBQ Turkey Sub

$16.00

Chicken & Greens Grinder Hot Sub

$17.00

Large Steak & Greens Grinder

$18.00


Pastas

Cavatelli

$17.00

Cheese Tortellini

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.00

Chicken Riggies

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.95

Chicken Riggies.

Gluten Free Chicken Riggies

$23.00

Gluten Free Ziti

With marinara sauce.

$21.00

Gluten Free Ziti.

Gnocchi

$17.00

Hats

$17.00

Jumbo Ravioli

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.00

Manicotti

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.00

Regular Rigatoni

$17.00

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$17.00

Stuffed Cheese & Spinach Rigatoni

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.00

Stuffed Shells Pasta

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.00

Ziti

Side salad & garlic bread

$17.00

Vodka Riggies

$18.95


Calzones & Rolls

Foot Long Calzone

Made to order foot long need 2 hour prep time.

$14.95

Sausage Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Antipasto Roll

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$33.00

Broccoli Roll

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Chicken Wing Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$30.00

Ham & Cheese Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Pepperoni Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Spinach Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$30.00

Eggplant Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Antipasto Roll

$32.00


Tossed Salads

Large Italian Antipasto Salad

$13.50

Large Italian Antipasto Salad.

Small Italian Antipasto Salad

$11.00

Large Greek Antipasto Salad

$17.50

Small Greek Antipasto Salad

$12.00

Small Greek Antipasto Salad.

Large Garden Salad

$13.50

Large Garden Salad.

Small Garden Salad

$10.00

Small Garden Salad.

Large Fresh Spinach Salad

Baby spinach, bacon, boiled eggs, fresh mushrooms, red onions, parm cheese, house croutons, topped with italian dressing

$15.00

Small Fresh Spinach Salad

Baby spinach, bacon, boiled eggs, fresh mushrooms, red onions, parm cheese, house croutons, topped w/ house Italian dressing.

$11.00

Large Chicken Caesar Salad

Romaine, red onion, eggs, croutons, fresh mushrooms, grilled chicken, pecorino romano, bacon. dressing: creamy caesar

$17.50

Large Chicken Caesar Salad.

Small Chicken Caesar Salad Small

$12.00


Greens

Greens Ala Tony

Escarole, garlic & spices, salami, prosciutto, hot soppressata, hot cherry peppers, onions, potatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese & breadcrumbs.

$18.00

Retail Antipasto

$9.00

Mini Sausage Roll

$14.00

House Soup

$6.00

Fried Meatballs & Long Hots

$15.00


Sides

Garlic Bread

$4.00

Side Fries

$3.00

Side Salad

$3.25

Side Salad.

Side Meatball

$2.00

BBQ

$1.95

Celery

$2.00

Blue Cheese

$2.00

Ranch

$1.95

Mild Sauce

$1.95

Medium Sauce

$1.95

Hot Sauce

$1.95

Marinara Sauce

$1.95

Oil & Vinegar

$0.00

SALSA

$7.00

Tonys Bru Cheesa

$8.50

Honey Mustard

$1.95

Tasty Sauce (Everything Sauce)

$1.95


Desserts

Blueberry Crumble Cheesecake

$8.00

Brownie

$5.00

Brownie.

Cannoli

Crispy cannoli shell filled with homemade sweet ricotta cheese filling.

$5.50

Cannoli.

Chocolate Cake

$8.00

Chocolate Cake.

Chocolate Cannoli

$6.00

Peanut Butter Pie

$8.50

Peanut Butter Pie.

Raspberry Cheesecake

$8.00

Strawberry Cheesecake

$8.50

Strawberry Cheesecake.

Tiramisu

$7.50

Tiramisu.

Toasted Almond Cream Cake

$7.50

Rice Krispy Square

$3.50

David's Gluten Free Brownie

$4.75

David's Gluten Free Brookie

$4.75


Beverages

20 oz Soda

$0.00

2 Liter

$0.00


Catering Menu

Large Tray Baked Baked Ziti

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$90.00

Large Tray Stuffed Shells

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$115.00

Large Tray Manicotti

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$115.00

Large Tray Tortellini

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$115.00

Large Tray Stuffed Rigatoni

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$115.00

Large Tray Cheese Ravoli

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Chicken Riggi

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$110.00

Vodka Riggi Large Tray

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$115.00

Large Tray Chicken Spin. Tom

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$125.00

Large Tray Hats & Broccoli

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Meat Lasagna

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$160.00

Veggie Lasagna Large Tray

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$160.00

Large Tray Eggplant Parm

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Eggplant Parm.

Large Tray Chicken Parm

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$130.00

Large Tray Chicken Parm.

Large Tray Chicken Marsala

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$130.00

Large Tray Chicken Francaise

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$145.00

Large Tray Chicken Florentine

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$140.00

Large Tray Greens Ala Tony

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$125.00

Large Tray Roasted Potatoes

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$80.00

Large Tray Roasted Chicken

Please allow a 24 Hour Notice on All Roasted Chicken Trays.

$125.00

Large Tray Grilled Chicken Breast

Made to order Rolls & Trays needs 24 hour (1 Day) prep time.

$140.00

Large Tray Sausage & Peppers

Made to order Sausage & peppers Tray need 24 hour prep time.

$135.00

Large Tray Meatballs in Sauce

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Mac Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Rice Pilaf

$80.00

Large Tray Antipasto Tray

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$95.00

Large Tray Greek Antipasto Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Spinach Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$90.00

Large Tray Chicken Caesar Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$120.00

Large Tray Garden Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$90.00

Large Tray Garden Salad.

Small Tray Baked Ziti

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$48.00

Small Tray Stuffed Shells

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$68.00

Small Tray Manicotti

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Stuffed Rigatoni

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Tortellini

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$68.00

Small Tray Cheese Ravoli

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Chicken Riggi

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$55.00

Vodka Riggi Small Tray

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$62.00

Small Tray Chicken Spin. Tom

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$67.60

Small Tray Hats & Broccoli

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Meat Lasagna

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$88.00

Veggie Lasagna Small Tray

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$85.00

Small Tray Eggplant Parm

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$68.00

Small Tray Eggplant Parm.

Small Tray Chicken Parm

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Chicken Parm.

Small Tray Chicken Marsala

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$70.00

Small Tray Chicken Francaise

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$75.00

Small Tray Chicken Florentine

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$70.00

Small Tray Greens Ala Tony

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$68.00

Small Tray Roasted Potatoes

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$42.00

Small Tray Roasted Chicken

Please allow a 24 Hour Notice on All Roasted Chicken Trays.

$65.00

Small Tray Grilled Chicken Breast

Made to order Rolls & Trays needs 24 hour (1 Day) prep time.

$70.00

Small Tray Rice Pilaf

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$44.00

Small Tray Sausagae & Peppers

Made to Order Sausage & Peppers Tray needs 24 Hour Prep Time

$74.00

Small Tray Meatballs in Sauce

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Mac Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$60.00

Small Tray Antipasto Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$47.00

Small Tray Greek Antipasto Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Spinach Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$55.00

Small Tray Chicken Caesar Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$65.00

Small Tray Garden Salad

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$45.00

Small Tray Garden Salad.

6 Foot Party Sub

Made to order Rolls & Trays needs 24 hour (1 Day) prep time.

$148.00

3 Foot Party Sub

Made to order Rolls & Trays needs 24 hour (1 Day) prep time.

$82.00

Distant Delivery Charge

$20.00

Sausage Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Antipasto Roll

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$33.00

Broccoli Roll

Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Chicken Wing Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$30.00

Ham & Cheese Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Pepperoni Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00

Spinach Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$30.00

Eggplant Roll

Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time.

$28.00


Happy Hour

4 PM - 6 PM

HH Mozzarella Sticks

$13.00

1/2 Order Greens

$18.25

HH French Fries

$6.00

HH Boneless Wings

$12.50+

HH Small (12") Pizza

$15.00

HH Vodka Riggies

$18.95

HH Dinings Meatballs & Long Hots

$15.00

Bacon Cheeseburger w/ Garlic Parm Fries

$17.95

Bacon Cheeseburger w/ Garlic Parm Fries.
Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar

Menu

Catering

About Tony’s

Delivery Range

Gift Cards

We're Hiring

Contact

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Tony's Pizzeria 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner